Making the right choices is hard. For startups, decisions about product development, hiring, or even daily operations can feel incredibly high-stakes. Startup decision making often feels like a minefield. This guide explores actionable tactics to approach these crucial moments, providing founders with a roadmap to better outcomes.
Table of Contents:
- Sharpening Your Decision-Making Skills
- Startup Decision Making at Scale
- Tackling Common Startup Decisions
- Conclusion
Sharpening Your Decision-Making Skills
Cognitive biases cloud our judgment, especially when facing uncertainty. Startups encounter uncertainty constantly. Recognizing this is the first step to better startup decisions.
Making the Implicit Explicit
Annie Duke highlights the importance of challenging personal biases as a leader and setting an example for your company. Documenting the decision-making process is crucial for startups. Writing things down, discussing different aspects with your team, and reviewing afterward creates a valuable guide for future decisions.
Thinking Beyond the Immediate
Startup leaders sometimes rely too much on gut feelings due to time pressures. Step back and ask what factors are relevant to this type of decision. Creating a decision rubric with your team before a tricky situation arises keeps startup decision making anchored.
Seeking Input, Not Groupthink
Gathering different perspectives is important. Make sure everyone gives their view individually to avoid groupthink. Having team members rank criteria offers insightful information that improves startup decision making.
Startup Decision Making at Scale
As your startup grows, your decision-making approach must adapt. Startup decision making must evolve as the company grows and its market share expands.
Process Isn’t the Enemy
The Harvard Business Review discussed how startup decision-making evolves at different scales. Don’t sacrifice process for speed. Define clear paths and processes. Well-defined processes enable you to make faster, more informed decisions without wasting time.
Review All Outcomes, Not Just Failures
Regularly review past decisions, even successful ones. This includes product iterations and internal strategy debates. This often-overlooked practice strengthens the team’s forecasting abilities.
This also aids in risk management as you analyze your thought processes. Reviewing all decisions helps refine the overall decision-making process within the startup.
The Small Decision Mindset
Look for smaller iterations when making big decisions. For example, can startup decision making about hiring become more agile? Are there small adjustments for better future options?
Tackling Common Startup Decisions
Let’s address specific examples of startup decision making in action.
Customer Discovery
Startup decision making requires feedback from design partners. Seek diverse opinions during customer discovery.
Remember, decisions with low cost or easy reversibility are best made quickly. Don’t take this for granted though.
One study found that asking potential customers similar questions and focusing on areas where they disagree yields valuable insights.
Hiring and Firing
| Decision | Speed | Focus |
|---|---|---|
| Hiring | Slow | Pre-determined criteria, diverse perspectives. |
| Firing | Fast (but thoughtfully) | Opportunity cost, pre-commitment. |
Early hiring mistakes can hurt growth. Don’t get bogged down with less impactful roles. Speed is beneficial when cost or reversibility is low. However, rushing big hires can derail your traction.
One effective method is for teams to collaboratively define attributes for job success ahead of time. This data-driven approach to decision making replaces “gut decisions” and establishes clear metrics for evaluation.
Firing involves difficult emotions. Thinking things through ahead of time is crucial, even for situations involving the founder. Pre-commitment contracts and benchmarks can offer structure in these tough choices.
“Bet the Company” Decisions & Winding Down
Big decisions affect your company’s perception, growth path, and even potential acquisition. Apply what you’ve learned from personnel decisions—prepare in advance. Check whether shutting down really hurts investors’ perceptions (spoiler: it doesn’t).
Use customer discovery insights and key benchmarks. Get outside opinions before detailed discussions or sharing potentially biased viewpoints. This transparency fosters trust and better decision-making when discussing outcomes like accepting funds to wind down.
While marketing tools are helpful for gathering market input, be cautious about advice to “pivot.” Focus on advice relevant to your specific niche. Pivoting should be a quality decision based on careful analysis, not external pressures.
Conclusion
Startup decision making isn’t about always being right. It’s about having a structure and a well-defined decision-making process. Acknowledge biases, embrace diverse opinions, and adapt through reflection. These strategies, implemented from early stages through growth, will lead to sustainable, informed growth. Open and honest dialogue is crucial, both individually and as a team.
Building a strong leadership team and clear decision processes ensures the business starts and grows on solid footing. This framework for decision-making will help visionary founders make good decisions and manage risk effectively. Startup founders need to recognize that it’s time to develop a robust framework for making decisions, not just relying on gut feelings. They must avoid the trap of adding features without thinking strategically about how it impacts the MVP you’re building.
Visionary founders should always consider the most strategic approach to decision-making and gauge its impact. Startup founders must develop an efficient decision-making process and make faster, informed decisions if they run a business. A structured approach allows the team to evaluate different focus areas and ensures every decision leads to a positive outcome. As your company grows, having a system and rubric in place for every big decision is vital.
Subscribe to my LEAN 360 newsletter to learn more about startup insights.
