The journey from startup founder to successful CEO is often tumultuous and filled with unique challenges and pitfalls. This is why many founders fail as CEOs. While founders typically possess the passion, vision, and drive necessary to start a company, the skills required to grow and manage a large, successful organization can differ vastly.
This dichotomy is why many startup founders fail as CEOs. Let’s explore the reasons behind this phenomenon, provide illustrative examples, and offer insights into how founders can navigate these challenges.
The Visionary vs. The Manager
The Founder’s Vision
Founders are often visionaries who can see opportunities where others do not. They are the ones who take the risk to turn an idea into a tangible product or service. Their passion and drive are crucial in the early stages of a company when the focus is on innovation, product development, and market fit.
Example: Steve Jobs
Steve Jobs, the co-founder of Apple, is a prime example of a visionary founder. His ability to envision and create groundbreaking products like the iPhone and the Mac revolutionized the tech industry. However, his initial stint as CEO was marked by difficulties in managing the company’s growth and navigating internal politics, which led to his ousting in 1985.
The CEO’s Management Skills
A CEO’s role, especially in a mature company, requires a different skill set. It involves strategic planning, operational efficiency, financial management, and often a more diplomatic approach to leadership. The CEO must balance short-term objectives with long-term goals, manage a large and diverse team, and ensure the company remains profitable and sustainable.
Example: John Sculley
John Sculley, who replaced Jobs as Apple’s CEO, brought the management experience from his time at PepsiCo. Sculley’s operational efficiency and marketing expertise helped Apple grow during the late 1980s. However, his lack of vision compared to Jobs led to challenges, and ultimately, it was Jobs’ return in 1997 that revitalized the company.
Common Challenges Faced by Founder-CEOs
Scaling the Organization
Founders often struggle with scaling their companies. What works for a startup of 10 people does not work for a company of 100 or 1,000. Scaling requires processes, systems, and a different leadership style, areas where many founders lack experience.
Example: Travis Kalanick
Travis Kalanick, the co-founder of Uber, exemplified this challenge. His aggressive leadership style helped Uber grow rapidly, but it also created a toxic corporate culture and numerous legal issues. Ultimately, he was forced to resign as CEO in 2017 due to these challenges.
Transitioning from Product Development to Management
In the early stages, founders are deeply involved in product development. As the company grows, the CEO must focus more on management and less on the product. This transition can be difficult for founders who are passionate about their product and less interested in day-to-day management.
Example: Elon Musk
Elon Musk, the founder of Tesla and SpaceX, has faced criticism for his hands-on approach to product development and engineering. While his visionary leadership has driven innovation, it has also led to management challenges at Tesla, including high executive turnover and production delays.
Developing a Diverse Skill Set
Successful CEOs need a broad skill set, including finance, operations, marketing, and human resources. Founders often excel in one area, such as technology or sales, but may lack expertise in other critical areas. This gap can hinder their effectiveness as CEOs.
Example: Jack Dorsey
Jack Dorsey, co-founder of Twitter and Square, struggled with balancing his dual CEO roles at both companies. His product vision and design strengths did not necessarily translate to effective day-to-day management, leading to operational challenges at Twitter.
Managing Stakeholders
As companies grow, managing relationships with investors, board members, employees, and customers becomes increasingly important. Founders may struggle with diplomacy and communication skills to keep all stakeholders aligned and satisfied.
Example: Adam Neumann
Adam Neumann, the co-founder of WeWork, failed to manage stakeholder expectations effectively. His ambitious vision and unconventional leadership led to significant financial losses and a failed IPO, resulting in his resignation in 2019.
How Founders Can Succeed as CEOs
Embrace Continuous Learning
Founders who succeed as CEOs often commit to continuous learning and personal development. They seek out mentors, attend leadership programs, and are open to feedback and self-improvement.
Example: Reed Hastings
Reed Hastings, the co-founder and CEO of Netflix, is known for his commitment to learning and adaptability. His willingness to pivot Netflix from a DVD rental service to a streaming giant and invest in original content has been key to the company’s success.
Build a Strong Executive Team
A strong executive team can complement a founder-CEO’s strengths and fill in their weaknesses. Founders should focus on hiring experienced leaders in areas where they lack expertise and empower them to take ownership of their domains.
Example: Mark Zuckerberg
Mark Zuckerberg, the co-founder and CEO of Facebook, has built a strong executive team to support the company’s growth. By bringing in experienced leaders like Sheryl Sandberg, Zuckerberg has been able to focus on long-term vision while ensuring operational excellence.
Develop Emotional Intelligence
Emotional intelligence (EQ) is critical for effective leadership. Founders with high EQ can manage their emotions, understand and influence others, and navigate complex interpersonal dynamics.
Example: Satya Nadella
Satya Nadella, who succeeded Steve Ballmer as Microsoft’s CEO, transformed the company’s culture with his empathetic leadership style. Although not a founder, his ability to connect with employees and stakeholders has been instrumental in Microsoft’s resurgence.
Focus on Strategic Vision
While operational management is crucial, maintaining a strategic vision is equally important. Founders who succeed as CEOs can balance day-to-day management with a focus on long-term goals and innovation.
Example: Jeff Bezos
Jeff Bezos, the founder of Amazon, successfully transitioned from startup founder to CEO of one of the world’s largest companies. His ability to maintain a long-term vision, such as focusing on customer obsession and investing in new markets, has been key to Amazon’s success.
Conclusion
The transition from founder to CEO is fraught with challenges, which is why many founders fail as CEOs. However, founders can succeed as CEOs by understanding the differences between these roles and developing the necessary skills. Embracing continuous learning, building a strong executive team, developing emotional intelligence, and maintaining a strategic vision are critical steps in this journey.
Ultimately, the ability to adapt and grow as a leader determines whether a founder can also be an effective CEO. While many founders may struggle with this transition, those who do can lead their companies to remarkable success.
For further reading on the topic, consider exploring the following resources:
- Harvard Business Review: When Founders Go Too Far
- Medium: Why Founders Fail as CEOs
- Forbes: How Founders Can Become Great CEOs
By learning from the experiences of others and focusing on personal and professional growth, founders can overcome the challenges of leading their companies through various stages of growth and ultimately achieve lasting success.
Subscribe to my LEAN 360 newsletter to learn more about startup insights.
